sus4
Senior Member
Japan - Japanese
- Dec 15, 2005
- #1
Hi,
According to one of the dictionaries I own, "dedicated to" cannot be followed by the original form of a verb; it must be followed by a noun, pronoun, or gerund, because "to" here is not a to-infinitive. However, I came across so many sentences using "dedicated to be" and "dedicated to do" on the Internet.
Could anyone explain this to me? Is it grammatically correct to use "dedicated to do..."?
Thanks!
D
Dale Dolores
Senior Member
Switzerland
Native: English
- Dec 15, 2005
- #2
Hi, sus4! I wouldn't use the internet as your source of gramatically correct English. You will find so many errors! I would not say "I am dedicated to do...". It is not correct.
Some ways you could use this phrase:
I am dedicated to my husband.
I am dedicated to making this world a better place.
M
M56
Banned
Madrid
Britain. English.
- Dec 15, 2005
- #3
sus4 said:
Hi,
According to one of the dictionaries I own, "dedicated to" cannot be followed by the original form of a verb; it must be followed by a noun, pronoun, or gerund, because "to" here is not a to-infinitive. However, I came across so many sentences using "dedicated to be" and "dedicated to do" on the Internet.
Could anyone explain this to me? Is it grammatically correct to use "dedicated to do..."?
Thanks!
I found only four examples in the British National Corpus (BNC):
"the ultimate in designer resorts, one enormous pleasure garden dedicated to give as much as possible to as many as"
"One needs to be dedicated to play rugby nowadays",
"The America First Committee was formed, dedicated to keep the nation out of the war and opposed to"
"a non-ideological, non-denominational, profit-making organization dedicated to bring together people from many different "
sus4
Senior Member
Japan - Japanese
- Dec 15, 2005
- #4
Hi joylolade, thanks for your help! I got confused because some of the sources I referred to were newspapers, government Web sites, and such.
Thanks M56! I didn't know of the British National Corpus. This seems like a great resource.
Kelly B
Curmodgeratrice
USA English
- Dec 15, 2005
- #5
I would have preferred the -ing form on those examples except for this one:"One needs to be dedicated to play rugby nowadays", This one is correct, because dedicated is an adjective here, not a verb:
One needs to be dedicated in order to play rugby.
M
M56
Banned
Madrid
Britain. English.
- Dec 15, 2005
- #6
sus4 said:
Hi joylolade, thanks for your help! I got confused because some of the sources I referred to were newspapers, government Web sites, and such.
Thanks M56! I didn't know of the British National Corpus. This seems like a great resource.
It is. Here's a link to it:
If you need help using it, just ask.
M
M56
Banned
Madrid
Britain. English.
- Dec 15, 2005
- #7
Kelly B said:
I would have preferred the -ing form on those examples except for this one:"One needs to be dedicated to play rugby nowadays", This one is correct, because dedicated is an adjective here, not a verb:
One needs to be dedicated in order to play rugby.
Yes, me too.
sevillista
Senior Member
Sevilla
Spain/Spanish
- Oct 24, 2011
- #8
Sorry, but I´m afraid I don´t get the adjective/verb difference.
One needs to be dedicated to breed a child
Right now I´m dedicated to breeding my child
Are they correct? Is that what you tried to explain? Thanks.
EStjarn
Senior Member
Spanish
- Oct 26, 2011
- #9
Are they correct? Is that what you tried to explain?
Syntactically, those sentences are correct; they reflect what has been said above. Semantically, you may want to have another look at them. (As for 'to breed a child', see this thread.)
Sorry, but I´m afraid I don´t get the adjective/verb difference.
The difference between
a) One needs to be dedicated to play rugby nowadays. (correct)
b) The committee was dedicated to keep the nation out of the war. (incorrect)
is that in a) 'to' is a preposition with the meaning 'in order to', whereas in b) 'to' is the particle of the infinitive 'to keep'. If we recast, the difference becomes more apparent:
a) To play rugby nowadays, one needs to be dedicated. (correct)
b) To keep the nation out of the war, the committee was dedicated. (incorrect)
R
ride7359
Senior Member
Rhode Island, USA
English
- Oct 26, 2011
- #10
One needs to be dedicated (in order) to raise a child.
Right now I'm dedicated to raising my child.
"To breed" is usually used in regard to animals when you want them to reproduce. They earn their living by breeding horses.
sevillista
Senior Member
Sevilla
Spain/Spanish
- Oct 26, 2011
- #11
Well, I really had in mind the action that a woman does with her baby when he/she is hungry. How would you call it then?
Estjarn, thanks for the explanation, it´s much more clearer now.
R
ride7359
Senior Member
Rhode Island, USA
English
- Oct 26, 2011
- #12
I'm sure this belongs in a different thread, but "to nurture" is a wide term that includes feeding and encouraging growth and development. In humans, nurturing is both physical and psychological. You can nurture plants, animals or anything that grows - even a new business.
Does that work?
sevillista
Senior Member
Sevilla
Spain/Spanish
- Oct 26, 2011
- #13
ride7359 said:
I'm sure this belongs in a different thread, but "to nurture" is a wide term that includes feeding and encouraging growth and development. In humans, nurturing is both physical and psychological. You can nurture plants, animals or anything that grows - even a new business.
Does that work?
According to Wordreference, it seems it´s "to breast-feed" the verb I had in mind when I wrote the sentence, but you´re right, it belongs in a different thread. Thanks for your help .
P
PureLand
Senior Member
Chinese
- Jan 22, 2019
- #14
1. I am determined and dedicated to continually improve my English.
2. I am determined and dedicated in order to continually improve my English.
3. I am determined and dedicated to continually improving my English.
Which one is correct? Thank you
Last edited:
DonnyB
Moderator Emeritus
Coventry, UK
English UK Southern Standard English
- Jan 22, 2019
- #15
PureLand said:
1. I am determined and dedicated to continually improve my English.
2. I am determined and dedicated in order to continually improve my English.
3. I am determined and dedicated to continually improving my English.Which one is correct?
Thank you
Only (3) works for me there.
I'd mark the other two as wrong.
P
PureLand
Senior Member
Chinese
- Jan 22, 2019
- #16
DonnyB said:
Only (3) works for me there.
I'd mark the other two as wrong.
Got it, DonnyB! Thank you soooo much for your answer!!!
velisarius
Senior Member
Greece
British English (Sussex)
- Jan 22, 2019
- #17
I am determined, and dedicated to continually improving my English.
The comma is needed because we can be "determined to do" something, but not to "doing" something.
P
PureLand
Senior Member
Chinese
- Jan 22, 2019
- #18
velisarius said:
I am determined, and dedicated to continually improving my English.
The comma is needed because we can be "determined to do" something, but not to "doing" something.
I see Thank you so much for your explanation, Velisarius
You must log in or register to reply here.